High Court acquits four KNH nurses in decade-long patient murder case


A murder case that has followed four Kenyatta National Hospital nurses for nearly a decade came to an end after the High Court found that the evidence presented could not support a conviction.

The court ruled that the prosecution failed to meet the legal standard required to prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt.

In a decision delivered on December 19, 2025, Lady Justice Kavedza Diana Rachel acquitted Priscilla Wairimu Njeru, Godfrey Murithi Gachora, Rosemary Nkonge, and Mary Muthoni Kamau, stating that the case a

The court ruled that the prosecution failed to meet the legal standard required to prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt.

In a decision delivered on December 19, 2025, Lady Justice Kavedza Diana Rachel acquitted Priscilla Wairimu Njeru, Godfrey Murithi Gachora, Rosemary Nkonge, and Mary Muthoni Kamau, stating that the case against them was not backed by solid proof.

The four nurses had been jointly charged with the murder of Cosmas Mutunga Kenyatta, who had been admitted to Ward 8C at KNH. Prosecutors claimed the incident occurred during the night of November 28 to 29, 2015, while the patient was under hospital care.

Evidence presented in court showed that relatives had visited the deceased on November 28 and found him alert and able to communicate.

The following morning, hospital staff discovered him dead in his bed with serious injuries, triggering investigations that focused on nurses who were on duty that night.

A total of 18 witnesses testified for the prosecution, among them family members, hospital employees, security officers, and investigators.

Security personnel told the court that a metal bar stained with blood was recovered from the ward and that blood was also found on bedding and nearby areas.

A government analyst later confirmed that blood collected from some exhibits matched the deceased’s DNA. However, the court noted that none of the forensic findings linked the recovered item or injuries to any of the accused nurses.

In their defence, the nurses said they carried out normal night duties such as administering medication and checking on patients. They told the court that they found the injured patient during early morning rounds and immediately informed hospital security. Each denied taking part in the death and said they had no disagreement or prior interaction with the deceased.

Justice Kavedza found that the prosecution’s case relied entirely on circumstantial evidence and failed to close critical gaps. She noted the absence of motive, lack of eyewitness testimony, and failure to directly connect the accused to the alleged murder weapon.

The court further observed that Ward 8C was not fully secured and had several access points, including doors and windows, creating the possibility that someone else could have entered the ward.

The judge added that the nurses’ actions after discovering the deceased reflected an appropriate medical response rather than an attempt to hide a crime.

In applying the principles governing circumstantial evidence and the presumption of innocence, the court held that alternative explanations had not been ruled out.

“While the death of the deceased was violent and tragic, the evidence does not irresistibly point to the accused persons as the perpetrators,” the judge stated.

As a result, all four nurses were acquitted of the murder charge and ordered to be released immediately unless otherwise lawfully held.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Inside Mwenda Thuranira’s growing lead over incumbent MP in Isiolo North

South C Tragedy Prompts Pleas for Immediate Action by Sakaja Against City Hall Officers

Public Statement on the South C Building Collapse — Nairobi