Audit Revelations Shake St. George's High School Leadership: Financial Discrepancies and Governance Failures Exposed
1.
Unveiling Corruption and Mismanagement at Kilifi County School
2.
School Fees Account Under
Scrutiny: A Principal’s Challenge
3.
Infrastructure Neglect and
Hazardous Conditions Plague School
4.
Audit Report Highlights Dire
Operational and Procurement Breaches
5.
Weak Governance and Financial
Irregularities Threaten School Stability
6.
Mismanagement of Public Funds:
The St. George’s School Crisis
7.
Audit Findings Reveal Health
Risks and Financial Chaos at School
Michael Mutambuki, the principal of St. George's High School in Kilifi County, finds himself in a precarious situation. The most recent report from the Auditor General for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2025, has instilled a sense of dread in Mutambuki, who is now required to address audit inquiries before the National Assembly.
The report uncovers discrepancies, mismanagement, embezzlement of public funds, and corruption related to the administration of the school fees account, among other issues.Inaccuracies
in the Financial Statements
The
statement of financial performance reflects school fund income-parents'
contributions of Kshs.32,847,494 while the ledger reflects Kshs.38,976,450
resulting to unexplained variance of Kshs.6,128,956. Further, the school fund
incomes- other receipts amount of Kshs.3,984,84'l which was not supported with
receipts ledger indicating the date of receipt, receipt number, source of
funds, students name, description of fee paid, amount and payment method.
ln
addition, the statement reflects tuition, operations, infrastructure, and boarding
and school fund expenditures amounting to Kshs.61 ,185,377 while the respective
ledgers reflect Kshs.60,314,172 resulting to unexplained variance of
Kshs.871,205. ln the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of the above
amounts reflected in the financial statements could not be confirmed.
Abandoned Project
Review
of project records held at the School revealed the site for construction of
class rooms was handed over on 22 August, 2022.
However,
Management explained that the construction was being implemented by the
Ministry of Education and they did not have any other documents including
signed contract, bills of quantities, payment details, certificates of
completed works or information in respect to start and completion dates for
this project.
Further,
physical verification carried out on 20 March, 2026 revealed pending works of
roofing, fitting doors, windows and furniture, electrical works, painting and
labelling and the contractor was not on site. ln the circumstances, value for
money invested in the project has not been realized.
The
statement of financial performance and as disclosed in Note 7 to the financial
statements reflects operations expenses of Kshs.8,212,813 out of which
Kshs.925,030 were purchases from various suppliers through direct procurement.
However,
these purchases did not meet the conditions set for direct procurements and was
contrary to Section 103 (2)(a) of the Public Procurement and Assets Disposal
Act, 2015 which states that a procuring entity may use direct procurement if
the goods, works or services are available only from a particular supplier or
contractor or a particular supplier or contractor has exclusive rights in
respect of the goods, works or services, and no reasonable alternative or
substitute exists ln the circumstances, Management of was in breach of the law.
Buildings with Asbestos Roofing
Physical
verification of the School's infrastructure conducted on 03 March, 2026
revealed that the school chapel/church was roofed with asbestos. This was
contrary to the fourth schedule of the Environmental Management and
Coordination (Waste Management) Regulations, 2006 which classifies materials
containing asbestos as hazardous and potentially carcinogenic and Ministry of
Environment, Climate Change and Forestry Circular Ref: MEF/EMCI111 dated 23
August, 2024 lhal directed on the removal of asbestos roofing by Government
agencies including offices, houses and learning institutions' premises as a
means of providing a clean, safe, healthy and sustainable environment.
ln
the circumstances, the School is exposed to hazardous and potential
carcinogenic health risks to the students and staff due to rooflng materials
containing asbestos.
Long
Outstanding Accounts Receivables
The
statement of assets and liabilities and as disclosed in Note 12 to the
financial statements reflects accounts receivables balance of Kshs.114,086,025.
lncluded
in the balance is an overdrawn account of Kshs.22,706,752 and other non-fees
receivables of Kshs.23,753,366 which have been outstanding for the last four
(4) years. However, there was no ageing analysis and policy on the impairment
of long outstanding fees arrears casting doubt on full recoverability of the
accounts receivable balance.
ln
the circumstances, the existence of effective mechanisms for debt management
could not be confirmed.
Weaknesses in the Management of Board Affairs
Review
of the School's governance arrangements revealed that there were no appointment
letters of members to the Board, no evidence of declarations of conflict of
interest and signed of attendance registers.
Further,
minutes for the board meeting held on 30 June, 2025 indicated membership of
eight instead of minimum of fourteen for a full board as per Section 56(1) of
the Basic Education Act, 2013.
ln
addition, only one meeting in twelve months was held which was less than the
prescribed minimum of three in twelve months as per Section 6 part lof the
Fourth Schedule of the Basic Education Act,2013. Further, there was no written
notification issued to members at least fourteen (14) days prior to the
meeting.
ln
the circumstances, the effectiveness of overall governance of the School could
not be confirmed.
Unsupported Operations Expenditure
The
statement of financial performance and as disclosed in Note 7 to the financial
statements reflects operations expenditure of Kshs.8,212,813. lncluded in the
expenditure are payments amounting to Kshs.1,991,634 that were not supported
with invoices, requisitions, local purchase orders, delivery notes and
inspection reports.
ln
the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of operations expenditure of
Kshs.8,212,813 could not be confirmed.
Unsupported Accounts Payables
The
statement of assets and liabilities and as disclosed in Note 13 to the
financial statements reflects accounts payables balance of Kshs.73,974,559,
however, the ledger reflects Kshs.7,O22,2B1 resulting to unexplained variance
of Kshs.66,952,278.
Further,
the balance includes trade creditors amount of Kshs.38,446,611 which was not
supported with invoices, local purchase orders or service orders and delivery notes.
Further, retention balance of Kshs.31,882,143 was not supported by bank
statements, certificate of works done and has not been allocated to any
supplier or contractors' account.
ln
the circumstances, the accuracy, completeness and occurrence of accounts
payables balance of Kshs.73,974,559 could not be confirmed.
Delayed Transfer of lnfrastructure Funds
The
statement of financial performance and as disclosed in Note 3 to the financial
statements reflects government grants for infrastructure amount Kshs.2,965,300
out of which Kshs.1 ,587,800 was transferred to infrastructure account after
fifty (55) days.
This
was contrary to Ministry of Education Circular Ref. No: MOE.HQS/3/13/3 dated 16
June, 2021 which directs that infrastructure grants as well as maintenance and
improvement funds be transferred to the school infrastructure account fifteen
(15) days upon receipt of the funds in the operations account.

Comments
Post a Comment